I’ve spent much of my academic career thinking about, writing about, and teaching about the medical humanities. Whether it has been with undergraduates, medical students, residents, or faculty, I’ve tried to use the arts and the humanities, especially poetry and reflective writing, to try to bring to bear the humanness of medicine—the vulnerability, suffering, death, beauty, and joy—alongside the technical training of medicine.
So, what exactly are the medical humanities? I’ll start with a definition of them, or I should say, my definition of them, which I describe as a field that gathers together the wisdom of the humanities (and the arts)—things like literature, poetry, narrative, history, philosophy, gender studies, cultural studies, and, for some, sociology and anthropology—to answer some of the most pressing human questions that are swirling all around medicine and medical training all of the time. Questions that our medical culture does not allow us to stop and slow down to consider.
Those of us in the medical humanities believe that the language of science is simply too narrow to discuss, reflect on, critique, embrace, or articulate answers to these questions. We believe that the humanities offer a richer, deeper, broader, and more critical language to answer the questions that science would deem unanswerable, immeasurable, or unquantifiable.
In fact, the medical humanities developed nearly 50 years ago in response to concerns that medicine and medical education had become too narrow and reductionistic. In the 1960s, philosophers, theologians, and clinicians started to point out that the medical care of the time failed to address the lived experience of patients and expressed concerns about how medical students, in particular, were being trained. Though the term “medical humanities” was not used at the time (and did not become widely used until the 1980s and 1990s), prominent people in medicine, like the famous physician and bioethicist Edmund Pellegrino, advocated for the introduction of the humanities into medical school. And in 1967, The Penn State College of Medicine established the Department of Humanities—the first-ever humanities department in a medical school in the US.
In the last 10 years or so, we’ve seen the emergence of the term health humanities. In many ways, this change in language was meant to widen the tent of the medical humanities. There are some who have felt as though the term “medical” leaves out the voices of people who are not typically seen as “practicing medicine”—like nurses or technicians or therapists or patients or families or caregivers. I tend to use the medical humanities and the health humanities interchangeably. I think if the medical humanities feels like it is too exclusive, then those of us in the field must do a better job of inviting and embracing every voice in the world of health, illness, and healing.
In some ways, the language doesn’t matter as much to me, as long as we are doing the work-- as long as we are creating spaces that give voice to what so many patients, families, and clinicians are going through.
It’s difficult for me to really explain why I think the medical humanities are so important without talking about what drew me to the field in the first place. When I was 19 years old, my mom was diagnosed with late-stage ovarian cancer. I took care of her mostly by myself for 2 ½ years before she died in the hospital. And it’s important for me to say that she died in the hospital and not at home, where she would have rather been. Even though my mom was a nurse, and she knew what was happening to her body, somehow, all of us, including her care team, had avoided conversations around death. Which might explain why she was offered a fifth-line chemotherapy treatment just eight hours before she died, with the suggestion that she would be discharged from the hospital to start treatment again. When she died later that night, I was so confused as to why none of her doctors were honest with her. Why none of them answered her questions about what her most recent scans looked like. Why they couldn’t tell the truth to someone who was clearly dying.
I was working on my master’s degree at the time. And I spent a fair amount of time intellectualizing all this and wondering why the end looked this way for my mom. And while I was initially angry that my mom’s doctors didn’t seem to have the moral courage to have this conversation with her, it wasn’t long before the anger turned to compassion when I learned that people in medicine get very little training in this area. So, of course they avoid conversations that they’re not comfortable with and have not been prepared for. Technically speaking, my mom’s doctors were excellent. They operated skillfully, they knew what labs and imaging to order, the right drugs to prescribe, and all the side effects to look out for—but when it came to navigating the kind of suffering that extends beyond the physical body, like so many others, they were simply unprepared to do so.
So, I suppose my desire to address the gaps in medical training is what drew me to the health humanities. I joke sometimes, when people would ask me, "How you teach a medical student empathy?" that you just have to make them suffer. It’s a joke, of course, but there’s some truth to it. Many of the students who I teach have come into medical school straight from undergrad, and while some of them have experienced significant suffering, the majority of them have not. And some of us start to wonder how you help a young trainee know what it’s like to get a terrible diagnosis or watch a child die—how to care for people who are living through the unimaginable—when they simply haven’t lived through anything like that themselves.
Enter the humanities. Nearly every person who cares for the sick crosses the threshold into the space where mortality and finitude—and the feelings of helplessness associated with them—come to the fore. Because of this, practicing medicine requires both scientific knowledge and a different kind of knowing, one that involves more than learning facts and skills via lectures and textbooks, one that develops an orientation toward self and others, a knowledge that is gained tacitly through dialogue, experience, and reflection. We know we cannot teach about the lived experience of suffering or healing through facts and statistics. So, perhaps, when you haven’t lived through something yourself, the closest we can get is poetry and narrative and visual art, literature, film, photography, and music. It is true that the humanities are valuable in and of themselves, but they can also potentially serve as the best proxies, the greatest teachers, about lived experience. Little bits of transformative magic right at our fingertips.
The humanities encourage comfort with ambiguity: literature, art, music, and theater expose people to conflicting interpretations, complex emotions, and situations without clear answers. The humanities are not the cut-and-dry multiple-choice questions that healthcare trainees are used to. For some of them, this is maddening. For others, it’s life-giving. And for all of them, who are walking into the messiness of caring for human beings, this is absolutely essential.
Medical humanist Ron Carson says that the medical humanities can educate the “moral imagination”—the emotional and intellectual capacity that allows a person to imagine something of what it might be like to be in the situation of someone else. The humanities draw on both our heads and our hearts, helping us to cognitively imagine and then subsequently feel what it might be like to be someone different.
And, practically speaking, the humanities can do more than inspire compassion and empathy. Things like written or dialogical reflection develop clinical wisdom and hone clinical reasoning. Engaging with the humanities encourages clinicians to slow down, question assumptions, consider multiple perspectives, and recognize the unpredictability of patients' experiences.
Ultimately, engagement with the humanities can help a student grow into the kind of clinician patients need—one who Carson says “knows how to listen for the storyline and hear the heartbeat of patients’ lives.” And for our practicing clinicians, reading and writing poetry and narratives, and reflecting with each other, reconnects them to meaning and purpose, to the reasons why they went into medicine in the first place. In my experience, these clinicians are hungry for these opportunities. To reflect on what’s happening to them. To make meaning out of tragedy, injustice, and seemingly meaningless suffering. This work reconnects clinicians and trainees to their patients, to each other, and to themselves. In a medical culture gripped by invulnerability and disconnection, the humanities just might be a necessary act of resistance—a way of reminding ourselves what it means to be human in an environment that so often can feel inhumane.